I don't see the stock diameter lightened pulley on their website. You may have accidentally ordered the accessory pulley and they in return accidenatlly sent you the underdrive pulley.
If you don't want to try it you can return it only if they will pick up the shipping cost. If not, keep it and sell it and make a small profit for your troubles.
If you don't want to try it you can return it only if they will pick up the shipping cost. If not, keep it and sell it and make a small profit for your troubles.